BEA counters Oracle: US$21 a share sounds better
- 25 October, 2007 21:00
BEA Systems's board of directors has named an acquisition price to competitor and suitor Oracle: US$21 (NZ$27.60) a share, US$4 more than Oracle's initial offer.
"We continue to believe that Oracle's unsolicited proposal to acquire BEA at US$17.00 per share significantly undervalues BEA, and is therefore not in the best interests of BEA shareholders," the company said in a statement.
Oracle on Tuesday set a deadline of Sunday for BEA to accept its "generous" original bid, which totals about US$6.7 billion (NZ$8.8 billion). The company also indicated it had no interest in a protracted merger battle.
But BEA declared on Thursday that the company's existing assets and future business prospects dictate a significantly higher sale price. The company said it has customers for its array of enterprise software among 75% of the Fortune Global 500, along with US$1 billion in cash reserves and no debt.
At US$21 per share, BEA would cost Oracle about US$8.3 billion (NZ$10.9 billion). BEA's stock was trading at US$17.60 a share midday Thursday.
BEA said it arrived at the US$21-per-share figure after talking to its financial advisor, Goldman Sachs. The company said it has authorised its attorneys to give a draft merger agreement to third parties willing to meet the price. The agreement would "provide for an appropriately high degree of certainty of closing," BEA said.
A successful purchase of BEA would significantly increase Oracle's standing in the middleware space. While some BEA assets would help round out Oracle's offerings, the companies overlap in key categories like web servers and ESB (enterprise service bus) products.
David O'Connell, a senior analyst with Nucleus Research in Wellesley, Massachusetts, said there is a major upside for Oracle in buying BEA, even at a higher price. "Is [BEA] worth Oracle paying a lot for? Yeah," O'Connell said. Oracle would gain BEA's customer base and technologies, a collective boon for Oracle's Fusion middleware and SOA (service-oriented architecture) offerings, the analyst noted.
Some have questioned the eventual fate of certain BEA technologies following a merger. But O'Connell said he does not expect major disruptions for existing customers. "My sense is they want to use Fusion to let people continue using those applications," he said. "That's what SOA and integration is all about."
An Oracle spokeswoman declined to comment on BEA's statement.