Five vendors join against Microsoft in EU case

IBM, Nokia, Oracle, RealNetworks and Red Hat pipe up

Five large technology companies have banded together to support the European Commission in its attempt to stop Microsoft using its PC operating systems monopoly to dominate the markets for workgroup server and media player software.

IBM, Nokia, Oracle, RealNetworks and Red Hat have applied as a group to intervene against Microsoft as the company appeals the Commission's antitrust ruling "because they are very concerned about Microsoft's anticompetitive conduct," according to their representative, Thomas Vinje, a partner with legal firm Clifford Chance LLP.

"Microsoft has been saying that the Commission stands alone and that it didn't have industry support. This demonstrates that that is untrue, that there is growing support for the Commission," Vinje says.

In March 2004, the Commission ordered Microsoft to pay a fine of €497 million (NZ$900 million), sell a version of its Windows operating system without Windows Media Player and allow other companies access to information needed to make their workgroup server products work smoothly with PCs running Windows. Microsoft appealed the ruling in June.

The five companies asked the European Union's Court of First Instance for leave to intervene in the appeal through an umbrella organisation, the European Committee for Interoperable Systems (ECIS). Only parties that can show that the case will directly affect them may apply to intervene. The court has already granted RealNetworks leave to intervene in the appeal. Intervenors are allowed to access the court's case file and make written comments on proceedings.

After Microsoft lodged its appeal, it began settling long-standing disputes with some of the companies and organisations that had opposed it in the case, including Sun Microsystems and the Computer and Communications Industry Association (CCIA).

Oracle and Red Hat are still members of the CCIA, but Nokia left when the association settled with Microsoft and withdrew from the European antitrust case. Vinje previously represented the CCIA in this antitrust case.

ECIS asked to intervene in the case in December or January — after the usual deadline for filing such requests had passed, Vinje says. The group asked for the deadline to be waived because of the exceptional circumstances surrounding the CCIA's withdrawal from the case, and it is now up to the court to decide whether to accept the ECIS request, he says.

Parties which apply for leave to intervene after the deadline may not normally make written interventions nor access the court's case file, but they may be allowed to intervene orally at hearings, according to court spokesman Christopher Fretwell. He won't say whether ECIS had applied for leave to intervene, saying the court can only confirm interventions when they are accepted or rejected.

Nokia has been a member of ECIS since the group was created in the 1990s, a company spokeswoman said, although she declined to comment further on the case. "I think it would be inappropriate for one member to comment for the group," says Arja Suominen, the company's vice president of corporate communications.

IBM too confirmed its membership of the group. "ECIS has a wide ranging agenda on behalf of greater ICT interoperability which is a goal that IBM supports because of the benefits that will accrue to all users of information and communication technology," says Fred McNeese, director of media relations for IBM in Europe, the Middle East and Africa.

"We believe that the case has raised a number of issues involving interoperability and we've decided to address those issues with other industry players," he says.

McNeese declined to comment on when IBM joined ECIS, or why the company didn't file to be an intervenor earlier or individually.

Oracle, RealNetworks and Red Hat did not immediately respond to a request for comment.

In a court order on March 9, the Court of First Instance granted a number of other companies and organisations leave to intervene in the case. On Microsoft's side are the Association for Competitive Technology, the Computing Technology Industry Association,, Exor, Mamut, MPS Broadband, Pace Micro Technology, Quantel, Tandberg Television and TeamSystem. In the Commission's corner are (trading as VideoBanner), the Free Software Foundation Europe, RealNetworks and the Software & Information Industry Association (SIIA).

The five members of ECIS already have a voice in the case, as they are members of the SIIA — but they may have trouble making themselves heard: the SIIA has 760 members, according to its website.

Join the newsletter!


Sign up to gain exclusive access to email subscriptions, event invitations, competitions, giveaways, and much more.

Membership is free, and your security and privacy remain protected. View our privacy policy before signing up.

Error: Please check your email address.

Tags antitrusteuropean commission

More about Computer and Communications Industry AssociationComputing Technology Industry AssociationEuropean CommissionFredFree Software FoundationIBM AustraliaMicrosoftMicro TechnologyNokiaOraclePace Micro TechnologyRealNetworksRed HatSun MicrosystemsTechnology

Show Comments