A 22-year-old University of Pennsylvania student, an associate of local botherder Owen "Akill" Walker, has been sentenced to three months in prison and probation time, following the worldwide botnet bust.
Walker was discharged without conviction in July.
Ryan Goldstein had been facing as much as five years in prison on a computer fraud charge after he was rounded up as part of the US Federal Bureau of Investigation'sOperation Bot Roast II.
In addition to the 90-day prison sentence, Goldstein, will also serve 90 days in a halfway house upon his release, followed by 180 days of home confinement. He will be on probation for five years, according to Michael Levy, chief of computer crimes with the US Attorney's Office for the Eastern District of Pennsylvania. He was also fined US$30,000 and must pay US$6,100 in restitution to the University of Pennsylvania, which was affected by an online distributed denial of service attack Goldstein helped orchestrate in February 2006.
Things could have been worse for the Ivy Leaguer, who cooperated with authorities. According to Levy, there was child pornography on Goldstein's computer, but he was not charged in connection with this.
In an email interview, Levy called the sentence "fair."
Goldstein's lawyer, Ronald Levine, said via email that his client "was charged with a misdemeanor and received a probationary sentence. He looks forward to getting on with his life."
Goldstein, who went by the online handle Digerati, wanted to wage an online war with three IRC (Internet Relay Chat) networks and a now-defunct website called ssgroup.org. Authorities say he was angry after being banned from at least one of the forums, and he talked teen-aged New Zealand hacker Walker into launching a DDOS (distributed denial of service) attack against these networks.
Walker, 19, known online as Akill, was also charged as part of Bot Roast II. He operated a large botnet network of hacked computers that he used for a variety of nefarious purposes, such as sending spam or launching online attacks. He pleaded guilty in New Zealand court in July and was fined, but given no prison time.
Though Walker got a lighter sentence than Goldstein, Levy said it's "hard to compare sentences in New Zealand with those in the US." And there were other differences between the Goldstein and Walker cases, he added. "Walker is younger and Goldstein had images of child pornography on his computer," he said.
In late February, a Penn server used to host configuration information for the botnet attack was so swamped with queries from the botnet network that it was inadvertently knocked offline.
Goldstein offered Walker passwords, and hacking software in exchange for launching the DDOS attack, authorities say.
Walker agreed to train his botnet on Goldstein's targets after the Penn student offered Walker log-in rights to a website and malicious Trojan horse software, Levy said during a November 2007 interview. "Did he pay him? It's in internet currency: 'Here's some tools for your kit bag,'" he said. "Did he send him money through this Paypal account? No."