If Megaupload users want their data, they're going to have to pay

The U.S. government says it doesn't have the data and isn't opposed to users retrieving it

U.S. federal prosecutors are fine with Megaupload users recovering their data -- as long as they pay for it.

The government's position was explained in a court filing on Friday concerning one of the many interesting side issues that has emerged from the shutdown of Megaupload, formerly one of the most highly trafficked file-sharing sites.

Prosecutors were responding to a motion filed by the Electronic Frontier Foundation in late March on behalf of Kyle Goodwin, an Ohio-based sports reporter who used Megaupload legitimately for storing videos.

Goodwin's hard drive crashed, and he lost access to the data he backed up on Megaupload when the site was shut down on Jan. 19 on criminal copyright infringement charges.

U.S. law allows for third parties who have an interest in forfeited property to make a claim. But the government argues that it only copied part of the Megaupload data and the physical servers were never seized.

Megaupload's 1,103 servers -- which hold upwards of 28 petabytes of data -- are still held by Carpathia Hosting, the government said.

"Access is not the issue -- if it was, Mr. Goodwin could simply hire a forensic expert to retrieve what he claims is his property and reimburse Carpathia for its associated costs," the response said. "The issue is that the process of identifying, copying, and returning Mr. Goodwin's data will be inordinately expensive, and Mr. Goodwin wants the government, or Megaupload, or Carpathia, or anyone other than himself, to bear the cost."

The government also suggested that if Megaupload or Carpathia violated a term of service or contract, Goodwin could "sue Megaupload or Carpathia or recover his losses."

The issue of what to do with Megaupload's data has been hanging around for a while. Carpathia contends it costs US$9,000 a day to maintain. Megaupload's assets are frozen, so it has asked a court to make the DOJ pay for preserving the data, which may be needed for its defense. So far, the issue remains unresolved.

Meanwhile, Megaupload founder Kim Dotcom is free on bail, living in his rented home near Auckland and awaiting extradition proceedings to begin in August. Dotcom along with Finn Batato, Julius Bencko, Sven Echternach, Mathias Ortmann, Andrus Nomm and Bram Van Der Kolk are charged with criminal copyright infringement and money laundering.

The men -- along with two companies -- are accused of collecting advertising and subscription fees from users for faster download speeds of material stored on Megaupload. Prosecutors allege the website and its operators collected US$175 million in criminal proceeds, costing copyright holders more than $500 billion in damages to copyright holders.

Send news tips and comments to jeremy_kirk@idg.com




I have a recording of the Kim Dotcom interview on TV3.
I have played it a few times.
Each time, and as events unfold, the simple truth becomes more apparent.
This was an illegal attempt by US authorities to close down a competitor to American companies.
Oh yeah, let's have free trade agreements and WTO so we Yanks can sell MacDonald's and Coke to other countries; but woe betide if you lot want to make some money.

The 'Coatesville Invasion' on 19 January was a scaled down version of the invasion of Iraq. it was about Commerce and Control. As with Iraq it was coated in platitudes of criminal behavior to cover for the 'bottom line' - yep, money, not morals!
I suppose Herr Dotcoms flash cars were 'weapons of mass distraction'

USA is the country that would not help its own people with Hurricane Katrina and has 70 million people who can't access healthcare (greater than the whole population of either France or Britain).
US was a great and admirable country 50 years ago but now has lost its way.
I guess now they will send in the marines to seize my computer, tablet, and iphone. Damn that metadata. Oh, and the TV3 recording.



The US of A has lost the plot but completely. The federal prosecutors are shown to be so corrupt any comparison with any Communistic regime fails. How dare they pander to the monopolies like Sony. The data is that of Goodwin, not of theirs, not of Sony's and their disgusting ilk. We need a class action of a few Trillion against the US of A to stop this rediculous behaviour against a person like Goodwin; "federal prosecutors" - what a disgusting bunch. Capitalism is about free spirit, about competition, not about protecting monopolistic faceless corporatism - how can a great country like the US lose it's way like this?! Shame on you disgusting corrupt US senators, policy and "federal" (or is it feral) law enforcement agencies.

Comments are now closed

Global tech firm bags NZ honours in Auckland